AJAX Preloader

Cayuga Lake Homes For Sale
New York

Cayuga Lake Homes For Sale
New York

Cayuga Lake, New York

Cayuga Lake real estate is regarded as a top ten market in New York for lake homes and land lots.

Typically there are around 120 land lots and homes for sale on Cayuga Lake.

Cayuga Lake homes for sale can range anywhere from $45,000 to $3 million, creating a total market value nearly $52 million.

Cayuga Lake Real Estate Agent

Mike Hardesty

Lake Homes Realty

(315) 501-0203

 
Mike  Hardesty
Learn More

Cayuga Lake
Real Estate Agent

Mike Hardesty

Mike  Hardesty

Lake Homes Realty

(315) 501-0203

My Listings ☐About me »

Contact Mike:

(315) 501-0203

 
 
 

Cayuga Lake Real Estate

Total Listings
67
Total Value
$45,365,490
Updated as of
05-08-2021

Cayuga Lake, New York

Cayuga Lake real estate is regarded as a top ten market in New York for lake homes and land lots.

Typically there are around 120 land lots and homes for sale on Cayuga Lake.

Cayuga Lake homes for sale can range anywhere from $45,000 to $3 million, creating a total market value nearly $52 million.

 

Cayuga Lake Real Estate for Sale

AJAX Preloader
26 Marina Road, Lansing, NY 14882 - Image 1
Waterfront

26 Marina Road

$3,200,000

Acreage: 13.95

Status: Active Under Contract

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

323 Main Street, Ledyard, NY 13026 - Image 1
Waterfront

323 Main Street

$2,749,000

Bedrooms: 8 |  Bathrooms: 11|  SF: 10970

Acreage: 0.5

Status: Active

mls logoNYSMLS-R1288712

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

5102 State Route 89, Romulus, NY 14541 - Image 1
Waterfront

5102 State Route 89

$2,475,000

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 5|  SF: 3714

Acreage: 144

Status: Active

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

53 Twin Glens Road, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1

53 Twin Glens Road

$1,950,000

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 4|  SF: 5296

Acreage: 3.43

Status: Active

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

140 Reach Run, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1
Price Change

140 Reach Run

$1,699,000

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 5|  SF: 7487

Acreage: 1.7

Status: Active Under Contract

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

6470 Timberlake Terrace, Romulus, NY 14521 - Image 1
Price Change
Waterfront

6470 Timberlake Terrace

$1,675,000

Acreage: 9.1

Status: Active

mls logoNYSMLS-R1223930

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

165 Eastlake Road, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1
New Listing

165 Eastlake Road

$1,499,000

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 5|  SF: 5729

Acreage: 1.9

Status: Active Under Contract

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

904 East Shore Drive, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1

904 East Shore Drive

$1,395,000

Bedrooms: 0 |  Bathrooms: 4|  SF: 6508

Acreage: 1.13

Status: Active Under Contract

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

3158 State Route 90, Ledyard, NY 13026 - Image 1
Waterfront

3158 State Route 90

$1,390,000

Bedrooms: 5 |  Bathrooms: 2|  SF: 2626

Acreage: 166

Status: Active

mls logoNYSMLS-R1299604

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

870 Highland Road, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1

870 Highland Road

$1,300,000

Bedrooms: 6 |  Bathrooms: 6|  SF: 5200

Acreage: 1.5

Status: Active Under Contract

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

369 Ellis Point Road, Ledyard, NY 13026 - Image 1
Waterfront

369 Ellis Point Road

$1,295,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 3|  SF: 5440

Acreage: 5

Status: Active

mls logoNYSMLS-B1326420

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

1603 Taughannock Boulevard, Ithaca, NY 14886 - Image 1
New Listing
Waterfront

1603 Taughannock Boulevard

$1,290,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 3|  SF: 3200

Acreage: 2.94

Status: Active

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

32 Tiger Lily Lane, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1: Main View

32 Tiger Lily Lane

$1,200,000

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 5|  SF: 5670

Acreage: 2

Status: Active

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

24 Tyler Road, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1

24 Tyler Road

$1,200,000

Bedrooms: 5 |  Bathrooms: 4|  SF: 4115

Acreage: 1.2

Status: Active

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

3863 State Route 90, Ledyard, NY 13160 - Image 1
Waterfront

3863 State Route 90

$997,500

Bedrooms: 6 |  Bathrooms: 5|  SF: 4444

Acreage: 11

Status: Active

mls logoNYSMLS-S1301220

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

1039 Taughannock Boulevard, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1
New Listing
Waterfront

1039 Taughannock Boulevard

$950,000

Bedrooms: 5 |  Bathrooms: 2|  SF: 2286

Acreage: 0.91

Status: Active

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

4283 Carrs Cove Road, Springport, NY 13160 - Image 1
Waterfront

4283 Carrs Cove Road

$899,000

Bedrooms: 2 |  Bathrooms: 1|  SF: 1200

Acreage: 1.77

Status: Pending

mls logoNYSMLS-R1297441

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

885 TAUGHANNOCK Boulevard, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1
Waterfront

885 TAUGHANNOCK Boulevard

$899,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 3|  SF: 2032

Acreage: 0.27

Status: Active Under Contract

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

1035 Taughannock Boulevard, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1
New Listing
Waterfront

1035 Taughannock Boulevard

$850,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2|  SF: 1872

Acreage: 0.94

Status: Active

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY

1308 East Shore Drive, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1

1308 East Shore Drive

$849,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 4|  SF: 3144

Acreage: 1.1

Status: Active

View Details »

Cayuga Lake, NY


« First< Prev1234Next >Last »
« First< PrevNext >Last »


Listings identified with the NYSAMLS IDX logo are provided courtesy of the NYSAMLS IDX Program. Information Is Believed To Be Accurate But Not Guaranteed. © 2021 NYSAMLS, Inc.

About Cayuga Lake

Longest of the Finger Lakes

Cayuga Lake is located within Ithaca, just over two hours from Buffalo and one hour from Rochester.

 

This lake covers over 42,000 acres of surface area and reaches depths up to 435 feet, making it the second deepest of the Finger Lakes. It also has a shoreline of 96 miles, making it the longest of the Finger Lakes.

 

This lake is not unique because of its size, but it also has over seven lakes within a few miles of its shore, including Lake Ontario.

 

Swimming, Fishing, and Boating

Cayuga Lake is a popular destination for boating, swimming, fishing, and other water sports due to its large size.

 

This lake is an excellent spot for trout and salmon fishing because of the colder waters found in the lake's deeper areas. Many of Cayuga's tributaries also offer a spring rainbow trout fishery and a fall landlocked salmon fishery. You can also find an abundance of perch, largemouth bass, and pickerel in the summer.

 

Drive the Scenic Byway

The Cayuga Lake Scenic Byway is an 87-mile loop surrounding Cayuga Lake that features the lake's scenic views, shores, and woodland landscapes. There are numerous historical, natural, and cultural attractions to stop at along the way.

 

If you want to take the boat instead of a car, the Cayuga Lake Blueway Trail is a public water recreation trail connecting non-motorized watercraft, including kayaks, standup paddleboards, canoes, and more on Cayuga Lake.

 

You can also take a wine tour on the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail. You can taste wine from over ten local wineries that sit along the shore of Cayuga Lake. Many of the wineries along the trail are award-winning and are considered a must-taste amongst local wine lovers.

 

A Scenic Way of Life

Whether you are looking to buy a family home, a full-time retirement residence, or a vacation rental, Cayuga Lake is an excellent choice.

Sell Your Lake Home

Off Market Properties

Cayuga Lake Amenities

Marinas

Ithaca Yacht Club

(607) 272-9171

Website

 

1090 Glenwood Rd

Ithaca, NY 14850

 

Finger Lakes Marine Service

(607) 533-4422

Website

 

44 Marina Rd

Lansing, NY 14882

 

Don's Marina Inc

(315) 364-8921

427 Powers Rd

King Ferry, NY 13081

 

Trade-A-Yacht Marinas

(315) 889-5086

Website

 

Marina Harbor Drive

Union Springs, NY 13160

 

Hibiscus Harbor

(315) 889-5086

31 Hibiscus Harbor Ln

Union Springs, NY 13160

 

Hideaway Harbor

(315) 889-5560

483 Backus Rd

Cayuga, NY 13034

 

Lockview Marina Inc

(315) 255-2936

Website

 

6655 NY-90

Cayuga, NY 13034

 

Golf Courses

Newman Municipal Golf Course

(607) 273-6262

Website

 

10 Pier Rd

Ithaca, NY 14850

 

Robert Trent Jones Golf Course

(607) 254-6531

Cornell University, 213 Warren Rd

Ithaca, NY 14850

 

Trumansburg Public Golf Course

(607) 387-8844

Website

 

23 Halsey St

Trumansburg, NY 14886

 

King Ferry Golf Club

(315) 364-7343

Website

 

1309 Clearview Rd

King Ferry, NY 13081

 

Silver Creek Golf Club

(315) 539-8076

Website

 

1790 E River St

Waterloo, NY 13165

 

Campgrounds

Spruce Row Campsite

(607) 387-9225

Website

 

2271 Kraft Rd

Ithaca, NY 14850

Sned-Acres Family Campground

(607) 869-9787

Website

 

6590 S Cayuga Lake Rd

Ovid, NY 14521

Twin Oaks Campgrounds

(315) 420-2269

Website

 

542 Fire Lane 14

Cayuga, NY 13034

Cayuga Lake Information

State: New York

Counties: Cayuga County, Seneca County, Tompkins County

Is the lake in the mountains: No

Ownership: Public

Acreage covered: 42,956

Miles of shoreline: 96

Average lake depth: 182 ft

Deepest lake depth: 435 ft

Shoreline part of national forest or park: None

Shoreline part of state park: None

Cayuga Lake Restrictions

Permit required to use lake: No

Jet Skis allowed: Yes

Motorized boats allowed: Yes

Boating restrictions: Yes-- must register boat

Dock restrictions: Yes-- must obtain permit

Houseboats allowed: Yes

Hospital nearest Cayuga Lake

Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hospitals

418 N Main St

Penn Yan, NY 14527

(315) 531-2000

Website

Other Cayuga Lake Information

Popular fish: Largemouth Bass, Smallmouth Bass, Black Crappie, Channel Catfish, Northern Pike, Brown Trout, Lake Trout, Rainbow Trout

Condos available: No

Notable period of annual events: Fishing Tournaments

Sailing clubs: Ithaca Yacht Club, Cornell Sailing Center

Known for: Great Fishing Area

History: Cayuga Lake was formed during the ice age.

Number of public boat ramps: 7

Nearest Airports to Cayuga Lake

Major

Syracuse Hancock International Airport

1000 Col Eileen Collins Blvd, Syracuse, NY 13212

60 miles away

Minor

Finger Lakes Regional Airport

2727 Airport Rd, Seneca Falls, NY 13148

4 miles away

26 Marina Road, Lansing, NY 14882 - Image 1
Waterfront

26 Marina Road

$3,200,000

Acreage: 13.95

Status: Active Under Contract

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
323 Main Street, Ledyard, NY 13026 - Image 1
Waterfront

323 Main Street

$2,749,000

Bedrooms: 8 |  Bathrooms: 11|  SF: 10970

Acreage: 0.5

Status: Active

mls logo

NYSMLS-R1288712

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
5102 State Route 89, Romulus, NY 14541 - Image 1
Waterfront

5102 State Route 89

$2,475,000

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 5|  SF: 3714

Acreage: 144

Status: Active

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
53 Twin Glens Road, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1

53 Twin Glens Road

$1,950,000

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 4|  SF: 5296

Acreage: 3.43

Status: Active

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
140 Reach Run, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1
Price Change

140 Reach Run

$1,699,000

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 5|  SF: 7487

Acreage: 1.7

Status: Active Under Contract

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
6470 Timberlake Terrace, Romulus, NY 14521 - Image 1
Price Change
Waterfront

6470 Timberlake Terrace

$1,675,000

Acreage: 9.1

Status: Active

mls logo

NYSMLS-R1223930

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
165 Eastlake Road, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1
New Listing

165 Eastlake Road

$1,499,000

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 5|  SF: 5729

Acreage: 1.9

Status: Active Under Contract

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
904 East Shore Drive, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1

904 East Shore Drive

$1,395,000

Bedrooms: 0 |  Bathrooms: 4|  SF: 6508

Acreage: 1.13

Status: Active Under Contract

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
3158 State Route 90, Ledyard, NY 13026 - Image 1
Waterfront

3158 State Route 90

$1,390,000

Bedrooms: 5 |  Bathrooms: 2|  SF: 2626

Acreage: 166

Status: Active

mls logo

NYSMLS-R1299604

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
870 Highland Road, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1

870 Highland Road

$1,300,000

Bedrooms: 6 |  Bathrooms: 6|  SF: 5200

Acreage: 1.5

Status: Active Under Contract

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
369 Ellis Point Road, Ledyard, NY 13026 - Image 1
Waterfront

369 Ellis Point Road

$1,295,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 3|  SF: 5440

Acreage: 5

Status: Active

mls logo

NYSMLS-B1326420

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
1603 Taughannock Boulevard, Ithaca, NY 14886 - Image 1
New Listing
Waterfront

1603 Taughannock Boulevard

$1,290,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 3|  SF: 3200

Acreage: 2.94

Status: Active

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
32 Tiger Lily Lane, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1: Main View

32 Tiger Lily Lane

$1,200,000

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 5|  SF: 5670

Acreage: 2

Status: Active

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
24 Tyler Road, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1

24 Tyler Road

$1,200,000

Bedrooms: 5 |  Bathrooms: 4|  SF: 4115

Acreage: 1.2

Status: Active

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
3863 State Route 90, Ledyard, NY 13160 - Image 1
Waterfront

3863 State Route 90

$997,500

Bedrooms: 6 |  Bathrooms: 5|  SF: 4444

Acreage: 11

Status: Active

mls logo

NYSMLS-S1301220

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
1039 Taughannock Boulevard, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1
New Listing
Waterfront

1039 Taughannock Boulevard

$950,000

Bedrooms: 5 |  Bathrooms: 2|  SF: 2286

Acreage: 0.91

Status: Active

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
4283 Carrs Cove Road, Springport, NY 13160 - Image 1
Waterfront

4283 Carrs Cove Road

$899,000

Bedrooms: 2 |  Bathrooms: 1|  SF: 1200

Acreage: 1.77

Status: Pending

mls logo

NYSMLS-R1297441

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
885 TAUGHANNOCK Boulevard, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1
Waterfront

885 TAUGHANNOCK Boulevard

$899,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 3|  SF: 2032

Acreage: 0.27

Status: Active Under Contract

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
1035 Taughannock Boulevard, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1
New Listing
Waterfront

1035 Taughannock Boulevard

$850,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2|  SF: 1872

Acreage: 0.94

Status: Active

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY
1308 East Shore Drive, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Image 1

1308 East Shore Drive

$849,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 4|  SF: 3144

Acreage: 1.1

Status: Active

View Details »Cayuga Lake, NY

« First< Prev1234Next >Last »
« First< PrevNext >Last »


Listings identified with the NYSAMLS IDX logo are provided courtesy of the NYSAMLS IDX Program. Information Is Believed To Be Accurate But Not Guaranteed. © 2021 NYSAMLS, Inc.

About Cayuga Lake

The Cayuga Lake real estate market is the fifth largest marketplace for lake property in New York.

 

The average list price for Cayuga Lake homes for sale is $567,000. Normally there are about 50 lake homes for sale at Cayuga Lake, and 40 listings for lots and land.

 

Cayuga Lake is one of New York's largest lakes, and has 96 miles of shoreline. Syracuse Hancock International Airport, the closest major airport, is only 60 miles away.

Cayuga Lake Information

State: New York

Counties: Cayuga County, Seneca County, Tompkins County

Is the lake in the mountains: No

Ownership: Public

Acreage covered: 42,956

Miles of shoreline: 96

Average lake depth: 182 ft

Deepest lake depth: 435 ft

Shoreline part of national forest or park: None

Shoreline part of state park: None

Cayuga Lake Restrictions

Permit required to use lake: No

Jet Skis allowed: Yes

Motorized boats allowed: Yes

Boating restrictions: Yes-- must register boat

Dock restrictions: Yes-- must obtain permit

Houseboats allowed: Yes

Hospital nearest Cayuga Lake

Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hospitals

418 N Main St

Penn Yan, NY 14527

(315) 531-2000

Website

Other Cayuga Lake Information

Popular fish: Largemouth Bass, Smallmouth Bass, Black Crappie, Channel Catfish, Northern Pike, Brown Trout, Lake Trout, Rainbow Trout

Condos available: No

Notable period of annual events: Fishing Tournaments

Sailing clubs: Ithaca Yacht Club, Cornell Sailing Center

Known for: Great Fishing Area

History: Cayuga Lake was formed during the ice age.

Number of public boat ramps: 7

Nearest Airports to Cayuga Lake

Major

Syracuse Hancock International Airport

1000 Col Eileen Collins Blvd, Syracuse, NY 13212

60 miles away

Minor

Finger Lakes Regional Airport

2727 Airport Rd, Seneca Falls, NY 13148

4 miles away

Cayuga Lake Amenities

Marinas

Ithaca Yacht Club

(607) 272-9171

Website

 

1090 Glenwood Rd

Ithaca, NY 14850

 

Finger Lakes Marine Service

(607) 533-4422

Website

 

44 Marina Rd

Lansing, NY 14882

 

Don's Marina Inc

(315) 364-8921

427 Powers Rd

King Ferry, NY 13081

 

Trade-A-Yacht Marinas

(315) 889-5086

Website

 

Marina Harbor Drive

Union Springs, NY 13160

 

Hibiscus Harbor

(315) 889-5086

31 Hibiscus Harbor Ln

Union Springs, NY 13160

 

Hideaway Harbor

(315) 889-5560

483 Backus Rd

Cayuga, NY 13034

 

Lockview Marina Inc

(315) 255-2936

Website

 

6655 NY-90

Cayuga, NY 13034

 

Golf Courses

Newman Municipal Golf Course

(607) 273-6262

Website

 

10 Pier Rd

Ithaca, NY 14850

 

Robert Trent Jones Golf Course

(607) 254-6531

Cornell University, 213 Warren Rd

Ithaca, NY 14850

 

Trumansburg Public Golf Course

(607) 387-8844

Website

 

23 Halsey St

Trumansburg, NY 14886

 

King Ferry Golf Club

(315) 364-7343

Website

 

1309 Clearview Rd

King Ferry, NY 13081

 

Silver Creek Golf Club

(315) 539-8076

Website

 

1790 E River St

Waterloo, NY 13165

 

Campgrounds

Spruce Row Campsite

(607) 387-9225

Website

 

2271 Kraft Rd

Ithaca, NY 14850

Sned-Acres Family Campground

(607) 869-9787

Website

 

6590 S Cayuga Lake Rd

Ovid, NY 14521

Twin Oaks Campgrounds

(315) 420-2269

Website

 

542 Fire Lane 14

Cayuga, NY 13034

New York Lakes