AJAX Preloader

Lake Shafer Homes For Sale
Indiana

Lake Shafer Homes For Sale
Indiana

Lake Shafer, Indiana

Lake Shafer real estate is considered the fourth largest market for lake homes and lake lots in Indiana.

 

There are typically 40 lake homes for sale on Lake Shafer at any given time. The lake will usually have 20 or so lake lots and land for sale.

 

Lake Shafer homes for sale have an average list price of $351,000, with many great homes at higher and lower prices.

Lake Shafer Real Estate

Total Listings
44
Total Value
$14,314,190
Updated as of
10-21-2020

Lake Shafer, Indiana

Lake Shafer real estate is considered the fourth largest market for lake homes and lake lots in Indiana.

 

There are typically 40 lake homes for sale on Lake Shafer at any given time. The lake will usually have 20 or so lake lots and land for sale.

 

Lake Shafer homes for sale have an average list price of $351,000, with many great homes at higher and lower prices.

 

Lake Shafer Real Estate for Sale

AJAX Preloader
7332 NE Shafer, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

7332 NE Shafer

$4,500,000

Bedrooms: 7 |  Bathrooms: 8

Acreage: 132

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

5140 E Bay Front, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1

5140 E Bay Front

$799,900

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 6

Acreage: 1.642

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

5251 E 350 N, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
New Listing
Waterfront

5251 E 350 N

$679,900

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 4

Acreage: 0.4

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

5259 E Willow, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

5259 E Willow

$635,000

Bedrooms: 6 |  Bathrooms: 3

Acreage: 0.44

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

2800 N Baers, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

2800 N Baers

$559,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 3

Acreage: 0.55

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

5486 E Golden Acre, Monticello, IN 47960-7128 - Image 1
Waterfront

5486 E Golden Acre

$489,900

Bedrooms: 5 |  Bathrooms: 4

Acreage: 0.3

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

5547 N West Shafer, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

5547 N West Shafer

$449,900

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.28

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

4363 E Jennings, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

4363 E Jennings

$449,900

Bedrooms: 5 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.28

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

5450 E Quiet Water, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

5450 E Quiet Water

$409,900

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 3

Acreage: 0.28

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

2316 N Sullivan, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

2316 N Sullivan

$399,900

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.162

Status: Pending

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

5407 NW Shafer, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
New Listing
Waterfront

5407 NW Shafer

$299,900

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.13

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

5027 N West Shafer, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

5027 N West Shafer

$289,900

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.26

Status: Pending

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

6817 N SKAGGS CT, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

6817 N SKAGGS CT

$239,900

Bedrooms: 2 |  Bathrooms: 1

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

5021 N WEST SHAFER DR, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

5021 N WEST SHAFER DR

$235,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

4297 N Silver Camp, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1

4297 N Silver Camp

$227,000

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 1

Acreage: 0.16

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

4512 E Oakcrest, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

4512 E Oakcrest

$219,900

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.187

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

2929 E Bradford, Monon, IN 47959 - Image 1
Waterfront

2929 E Bradford

$214,900

Bedrooms: 2 |  Bathrooms: 1

Acreage: 0.37

Status: Pending

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

6551 N 300 E, Monon, IN 47959 - Image 1

6551 N 300 E

$199,900

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.341

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

6879 N Chamber, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

6879 N Chamber

$198,800

Bedrooms: 2 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.2531

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN

6783 N Skaggs, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

6783 N Skaggs

$190,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.34

Status: Pending

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »

Lake Shafer, IN


« First< Prev123Next >Last »
« First< PrevNext >Last »


About Lake Shafer

35 Miles to Lafayette, Indiana

 

Lake Shafer has a surface area of 2.02 square miles and is one of two lakes in the Twin Lakes area of Monticello, Indiana. It was created in 1920, along with Lake Freeman, when two dams were built outside Monticello on the Tippecanoe River. Lake Schafer is the more commercialized of the two lakes, mainly due to the Indiana Beach Amusement Park & Camp-Resort.

Make the quick, 35 miles drive to Lafayette, Indiana, and enjoy the attractions there.

 

Enjoy the Lake

 

Residents can take a dip in the lake, a trip on the boat, or a cast of the line is possible on Lake Shafer. Pontoon boats are a popular favorite for cruising Lake Shafer.

On the western shore is the Tippecanoe Golf Course. This club is semi-private, meaning it is open to the public, so those who would like can come and play the 18-hole course, golf leagues, and the bar & grill.

For the avid fishermen or the occasional hobbyist, you can catch catfish, crappie, bluegill, carp, bass, and much more.

 

Enjoy Time in Monticello, Indiana

 

Monticello's town rests on the western side of Lake Shafer and is a great place to shop, eat, and enjoy life on the lake.

One of the most significant area attractions is the Indiana Beach Boardwalk Resort. Get a view of scenic Lake Shafer while having the time of your life on the Ferris wheel. The park has roller coasters, thrilling rides, fried foods, and lots of fun.

Raise a glass at Whyte Horse Winery or Fruitshine Wine. You might even find your new favorite flavor.

 

Enjoy the Fun on Lake Shafer

 

Whether you are looking to buy a family home, a full-time retirement residence, or find a vacation rental, Lake Shafer is an excellent choice.

Sell Your Lake Home

Off Market Properties

Lake Shafer Information

State: Indiana

7332 NE Shafer, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

7332 NE Shafer

$4,500,000

Bedrooms: 7 |  Bathrooms: 8

Acreage: 132

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
5140 E Bay Front, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1

5140 E Bay Front

$799,900

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 6

Acreage: 1.642

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
5251 E 350 N, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
New Listing
Waterfront

5251 E 350 N

$679,900

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 4

Acreage: 0.4

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
5259 E Willow, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

5259 E Willow

$635,000

Bedrooms: 6 |  Bathrooms: 3

Acreage: 0.44

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
2800 N Baers, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

2800 N Baers

$559,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 3

Acreage: 0.55

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
5486 E Golden Acre, Monticello, IN 47960-7128 - Image 1
Waterfront

5486 E Golden Acre

$489,900

Bedrooms: 5 |  Bathrooms: 4

Acreage: 0.3

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
5547 N West Shafer, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

5547 N West Shafer

$449,900

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.28

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
4363 E Jennings, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

4363 E Jennings

$449,900

Bedrooms: 5 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.28

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
5450 E Quiet Water, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

5450 E Quiet Water

$409,900

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 3

Acreage: 0.28

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
2316 N Sullivan, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

2316 N Sullivan

$399,900

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.162

Status: Pending

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
5407 NW Shafer, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
New Listing
Waterfront

5407 NW Shafer

$299,900

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.13

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
5027 N West Shafer, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

5027 N West Shafer

$289,900

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.26

Status: Pending

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
6817 N SKAGGS CT, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

6817 N SKAGGS CT

$239,900

Bedrooms: 2 |  Bathrooms: 1

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
5021 N WEST SHAFER DR, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

5021 N WEST SHAFER DR

$235,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
4297 N Silver Camp, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1

4297 N Silver Camp

$227,000

Bedrooms: 4 |  Bathrooms: 1

Acreage: 0.16

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
4512 E Oakcrest, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

4512 E Oakcrest

$219,900

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.187

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
2929 E Bradford, Monon, IN 47959 - Image 1
Waterfront

2929 E Bradford

$214,900

Bedrooms: 2 |  Bathrooms: 1

Acreage: 0.37

Status: Pending

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
6551 N 300 E, Monon, IN 47959 - Image 1

6551 N 300 E

$199,900

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.341

Status: Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
6879 N Chamber, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

6879 N Chamber

$198,800

Bedrooms: 2 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.2531

Status: Active

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN
6783 N Skaggs, Monticello, IN 47960 - Image 1
Waterfront

6783 N Skaggs

$190,000

Bedrooms: 3 |  Bathrooms: 2

Acreage: 0.34

Status: Pending

IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.

View Details »Lake Shafer, IN

« First< Prev123Next >Last »
« First< PrevNext >Last »


About Lake Shafer

Lake Shafer real estate is considered the fourth largest market for lake homes and lake lots in Indiana.

 

There are typically 40 lake homes for sale on Lake Shafer at any given time. The lake will usually have 20 or so lake lots and land for sale.

 

Lake Shafer homes for sale have an average list price of $351,000, with many great homes at higher and lower prices.

Lake Shafer Information

State: Indiana

Indiana Lakes