The Good and Bad of Relisting a Home for Sale

by on

Senior couple meeting Lake Homes Realty real estate agent

Even celebrities can struggle to sell a home, as discussed in Natalie Way‘s recent article Christie Brinkley Relists Her 2 Homes in the Hamptons: Why Haven’t They Sold Yet?

Brinkley’s homes are luxury properties, much like many lake homes across the country. Unlike other homes, such high-end and niche-market homes face challenges that other homes don’t when it comes to selling fast.

These types of homes are all discretionary purchases, meaning their purchase is optional. Like dinner at a high-end restaurant, no one has to pay that much just to have food, or in this case, shelter.

Because of this, selling luxury homes often requires more time on the market. Sellers have to wait to match up with a buyer that has both the means to purchase such a property AND the inclination to buy now.

The more expensive the home, the longer sellers should be prepared to have their home listed. This extended time commitment is just one of many reasons sellers may choose to take their home off the market and relist it later.

Why Homes are Relisted

Lake house locatedon the southern shores of Lake Rosseau
Photo courtesy of Muskoka Living.

High-priced homes rarely sell in a timely fashion. This can be attributed to several reasons:

  • The home was previously over-priced for that market and wasn’t going to sell.
  • Real estate market conditions have changed.
  • As a sales strategy, home is removed from the market in hopes it will appear “new” to the market sellers relist.
  • The homeowner has a change of heart about selling, then recommits to selling.
  • Sellers decide to use the home for a period of time, perhaps as a break from the interruptions caused by showings and selling.
  • The owner chooses to try a different real estate agent and/or a different marketing strategy.
  • The owner has “finally had enough” and is ready to be more aggressive in price and strategy to get the home sold.

Some of these factors sellers have no control over, such as the real estate market changing; others are just part of life.

Risks of Relisting a Home

Door County, Wisconsin lake house landscaping
Photo courtesy of Architectural Digest.

Relisting a home for sale is not without some market challenges. Some of these risks include:

  • Today’s knowledgeable home buyers (and local agents) know this property is not a new listing. Buyers may wonder if the home has some problem that is making it difficult to sell.
  • The home may get a reputation as having “been on the market forever.”
  • Taking a home off the market and relisting at a new price may lead buyers to believe if they wait long enough, the price may drop again.
  • If a home isn’t on the market, it can’t sell. During the time the home is unlisted, sellers are missing out on buyers that could come along.

Tips on Relisting a Home for Sale

Log lake home at night
Photo courtesy of BPImaging.

Relisting a home may not be a magical solution, but there are steps to take that help make the most of relisting the home for sale.

  • The marketing strategy must be very different when sellers relist. A new approach is needed to be successful before dropping the home back onto the market.
  • Make a meaningful change in the price.  This signals to buyers the seller is serious about a sale.
  • Update the property in some manner, but don’t go overboard since some of this money will not be recouped. However, yard landscaping, new paint, new carpet, or better staging can help a home sell faster.

There are really only two reasons a home does not sell: it is not marketed well or priced correctly.  However, the higher-priced the home, or the more specialized the home is (like a lake home), the more time it usually takes to sell.

Removing the home from the market and relisting is one approach used by people selling such homes. Though it does come with some risks, relisting can sometimes be another useful tool in the sales plan.

Still having trouble selling your lake home? Read “3 Biggest Mistakes to Avoid When Selling Your Lake Home“.

Considering Selling Your Lake Real Estate - Learn More Looking for Your Dream Lake Homes? Start Here

Glenn S. Phillips is the CEO of Lake Homes Realty. He is also an author and speaker. When not thinking about real estate and technology, he periodically plays his ugly tuba (complete with a bullet hole), enjoys exploring cognitive thinking, and prefers dark chocolate.

{ 5 comments… read them below or add one }

EDcook Real Estate October 16, 2018 at 4:18 am

Well written and to the point! Will save as a resource. Thank you!


Yoshiko Flora May 3, 2019 at 2:38 am

I find it helpful when you shared your tip that a person who is planning to relist their house for sale should try a different marketing approach before doing so. Aside from that, one should also think about asking for help from a real estate brokerage firm. With their help, they can get information on what price should it be listed as to how to stage the home to make it more appealing to buyers.


Matt September 12, 2019 at 3:33 pm

Yet another post I’m going share with my buddies on Facebook. Thanks!


Westrom Group January 9, 2020 at 5:45 am

Hi Gleen! Thanks for sharing the post.


James September 14, 2020 at 4:26 am

That was really a nice piece of content, simply elaborated. Thanks! for sharing your reviews and tips…


Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: